US District Judge Arun Subramaniam has denied Sean “Diddy” Combs’ request to be placed under house arrest at his luxury Star Island property in Florida. The hip-hop mogul, awaiting trial on sex trafficking and abuse charges, proposed a $35 million mansion as an alternative to his current detention at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn. The judge rejected the motion, asserting that it would not mitigate the risks posed by Combs. ‘ Perceived Obstruction and Dangerousness.
Inside ‘Star Island’
As the trial progresses, the attraction of Star Island draws attention. Known for its exclusivity, the island boasts luxury homes, waterfront views and proximity to Miami’s amenities. Here’s what makes it unique, as reported by Fox Business:
- In 2003, Diddy bought a nine-bedroom mansion for $14.5 million.
- In 2021, Diddy purchased a neighboring estate for $35 million, adding an 8,000-square-foot home with six bedrooms and 10 bathrooms to his collection.
- Accessibility: Accessible only by a bridge or private dock.
- Reputation: Home to A-listers including Jennifer Lopez and Gloria Estefan.
- Privacy: Gated community with private security.
- Amenities: Close to downtown Miami, top restaurants and the airport.
‘Defendant cannot be trusted’
Combs’ lawyers argued during Friday’s hearing that the musician should be allowed to prepare for the May 2024 trial under strict supervision in his Florida mansion or Manhattan apartment.
The defense insisted the arrangement would be “more restrictive” than his current prison. “It’s impossible for him not to follow the rules,” said attorney Tenny Geragos, highlighting Combs’ willingness to follow such conditions.
However, prosecutors maintained that none of the conditions could ensure public safety or prevent interference in the case. They accused Combs of organizing a social media campaign to influence judges and using intermediaries to contact potential witnesses while in custody.
“This is about accountability,” said Assistant U.S. Attorney Kristy Slavick. “The defendant cannot be trusted.”
Judge’s decision
Despite defense arguments, Justice Subramaniam rejected the plea outright. “It won’t work,” he said, talking about the need for strict detention to prevent any possible tampering or threats to witnesses.
Combs remains incarcerated in a Brooklyn jail as his trial approaches. The court is expected to rule on additional bail applications in the coming weeks, but the judge’s firm stance suggests a high bar for any future appeals.